Orch or theory debunked reddit
Orch or theory debunked reddit. One of the below commenters said what the motive was, and that was to make mothers feel guilty for working in the workforce, their participation had actually risen before there was a second wave feminist movement in the late 1960s and early 1970s. This orchestrated OR activity (‘Orch OR’) is taken to result in moments of conscious awareness and/or choice. Feb 14, 2019 · We proposed in the mid 1990’s that consciousness depends on biologically “orchestrated” coherent quantum processes in collections of microtubules within brain neurons, that these quantum processes correlate with, and regulate, neuronal synaptic and membrane activity, and that the continuous Schrödinger evolution of each such process terminates in accordance with the specific Diósi Oct 4, 2022 · Authentic Orch OR based on P-OR remains completely plausible. I also think this isn't directly in opposition to the classic idea of "fight or flight" which has more to do with the body getting ready for an immediate intense physical activity during times of stress (which could be running or fighting or even working hard alongside It seems to me that Orch OR theory is trying to explain human self consciousness. Officially debunking the theory would be like stating "No, it really WAS that bad". We also introduce a novel suggestion of 'beat frequencies' of faster microtubule vibrations as a possible source of the observed electro-encephalographic ('EEG') correlates of consciousness. Also related, there was The Physics of Immortality, by Frank Tippler. Orch OR has broad explanatory power, and is easily falsifiable. • Microtubule ‘quantum channels’ in which anesthetics erase consciousness are identified. m. 2. There is nothing wrong with being relevant, I realize I made it seem like my problem was with riding the trend. I was fascinated by the material, but actually I was a die-hard atheist at the time and I thought they were full of crap. TIL of the now debunked Nemesis Star Theory postulating Sun has a twin Death star, to explain periodic mass extinctions. Wait, how did JWT debunked Big Bang Theory? It has taken pictures of the earliest galaxies closer to the source of the Big Bang & recently it has taken a pic of another galaxy which has claimed to have been 200 - 300 million years closer to the source of where the Big Bang actually occurred so JWT is kind of being closer towards proving BBT rather than debunking it. 5 %âãÏÓ 543 0 obj > endobj 567 0 obj >/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[87B7098B0132BB7E726DA7F6A9737516>]/Index[543 50]/Info 542 0 R/Length 106/Prev 2137418/Root 544 yea thats what i heard about the theory when watching the debunking videos. Keywords: Consciousness; Orch OR; anesthesia; microtubule; orchestrated objective reduction; pyramidal neuron; quantum computing; tubulin. What is the Orch-Or Consciousness Theory? The Orch-Or Consciousness Theory is a scientific theory proposed by physicist Sir Roger Penrose and anesthesiologist Stuart Hameroff. Acknowledgments Jun 13, 2022 · More information: Maaneli Derakhshani et al, At the crossroad of the search for spontaneous radiation and the Orch OR consciousness theory, Physics of Life Reviews (2022). As far as I knew, nobody 'debunked' it as much as deemed it too speculative and based on other theories to be viable. • Evidence for warm quantum vibrations in brain microtubules is cited. Aug 25, 2021 · Orch OR’s critics argue that any quantum coherence inside microtubules would fall apart in the warm and noisy environs of grey matter long before it could have any effect on the workings of neurons. This thread is useful, and the first comment in it links to a really good explanation of the theory and its problems. Its proponents are not usually trying to necessarily claim the price you pay in the store is determined by labor time because obviously this isn't true, it's determined by whatever the businessman wants to and is able to charge for the item given a supply and demand intersection. The only theory I've ever heard that answers that in a way that is at all compelling to me is Stoned Ape. This is an attempt to create a definitive guide towards debunking this Psudo-History. g… I don’t think that needs to be debunked. I can Debunk it. It's a theory to explain how social labor is allocated in a society of generalized commodity exchange. The way I've generally seen the Marxian Labor Theory of Value (LTV) described is as a philosophical idea of value. Adrenochrome forms as a decomposition product of adrenaline, and therefore it exists in old epipens. Nov 21, 2014 · 1. Nov 4, 2021 · For Carlson, Strong Emergence is a vintage, debunked investigation into the existence of a soul, a big problem for physics and a big part of the Orch OR theory. Perhaps a bit confusingly, it's the theory that humans have their origins within Africa, and spread to the rest of the world by moving out of Africa. It implies this is a common theory in neuroscience and fails to properly emphasize the negative findings. Quantum Consciousness, also called Orch OR, says nah fuck that, there is a real reality and we are really interacting with it. The argument makes a probabilistic claim that we are most probably living in a simulation as the number of simulated universes would be much greater than the one real universe in technological advanced civilization. What are the main problems with the Orch-Or The theory for researching consciousness and thus the soul is called 'Orch-OR' (ORCHestrated Objective Reduction) and was developed in the 1990s by the physicists Roger Penrose (pictured) and Stuart Hameroff. In the mid-1990s he teamed with eminent British physicist and Nobel Laureate Sir Roger Penrose to develop a controversial quantum theory of consciousness (‘orchestrated objective reduction’, ‘Orch OR’) based on microtubule quantum computing. Penrose originally proposed some sort of quantum gravity effects in the brain because of the Penrose-Lucas argument concerning Godel's theorem--Penrose was arguing that the functional capabilities of mathematician's brains must go beyond those of computational systems, but the argument wasn't really saying anything one way or another about the "hard problem" since that deals exclusively with In the mid-1990s Hameroff teamed with British physicist Sir Roger Penrose to develop the controversial theory of consciousness called “orchestrated objective reduction” – Orch OR theory – in which consciousness derives from quantum computations in microtubules inside brain neurons, quantum computations connected to the fine- scale I would argue consciousness has indeed "been found", it just doesn't meet our expectations. I'd be super appreciative to anyone who can explain Orch-Or like I'm 5. However, these experiments are The closest anyone has ever come to "debunking" the LTV is Bortkiewicz back in the early 1900s. But the Penrose-Hameroff model of what you’d call quantum consciousness was a scientific non-starter. I was wondering if anyone can give good scientific, and quantitative if possible, evidence to debunk the hollow earth theory. I read about Penrose when I was a science nerd growing up in the 90s. Your weight is the temperature and eating is turning on the heater. In each case their aim was Some early objections about living matter being too "warm and wet" (i. He's right in the middle of all the sound and commotion and doesn't “They believe that they have found carriers of consciousness, the elements that accumulate information during life, and “drain” consciousness somewhere else after death. But unofficially, you can safely assume there's nothing to it. Basics: To debunk the Out of India Theory (hereinafter, OIT), you need to understand what is the scholarly view of Indo-Aryan migrations. Aug 15, 1998 · Hameroff S (2013) Quantum mathematical cognition requires quantum brain biology: The “Orch OR” theory, Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 10. The DP form of OR is related to the fundamentals of quantum mechanics and space–time geometry, so Orch OR suggests that there is a connection between the brain's biomolecular processes and the basic structure of the universe. org/wiki/Orchestrated_objective_reduction. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Explorations of the Paranormal, UFOs, Ancient Cultures, Cryptozoology… The funny thing about this so called 'conspiracy theory' is that it's easy to provide irrefutable proof, and for some reason nobody who makes these lists ever seems to think of it (although it was featured on Mythbusters). It is asserted with an example of a menial manufacturing role, typically the assembly of a mundane commodity such as a teddy bear or doll, the most recent 'example' asserted to me by a fascist, the making of In fact, the authors explicitly state: With the exception of the SAP out-of Africa dispersion based mainly on genetic data (2), the history of human populations in Eurasia may not have been the result of a few high-impact replacement waves of dispersals from Africa, but a much more complex puzzle of dispersals and contacts among populations within and outside continents. 15 votes, 10 comments. There are fundamental problems with Marx's Labor theory of value, not the least of which is that Marx never settled on a theory and contradicted himself across multiple works. Secret Treaties theory has been debunked Debunked Reached out to a few people I could find with connections to the band Secret Treaties after a recent post speculating on them as a possible artist of EKT, and I've confirmed from two people close to the members that Secret Treaties has no involvement with EKT. Neo-Nazis love to say “Out of Africa has been DEBUNKED! See! This random 8 million year old hominid species from wherever is proof! I ain’t related to no dang ol’ stankin naygers! Now let’s git em!”. This hypothesis represents an exciting frontier for future scientific inquiry into the nature of consciousness and the potential for accessing . To oversimplify, there is a hypothised homeland of "Aryans" (which is not the Aryans that Hitler states) known as the I am familiar with the proposed mechanisms for creating a nuclear winter (firestorms in enough cities due to a nuclear war). All I can say is that the people writing these books are either deluded or actively lying to you and making it sound scientific. Edit: Downvote all you want. I’ve seen a great deal of controversy about this theory of consciousness. Namaskaram, We are a friendly and user-focused community for Redditors from India. Veganism: A philosophy and way of living which seeks to exclude—as far as is possible and practicable—all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose; and by extension, promotes the development and use of animal-free alternatives for the benefit of animals, humans and the environment. I'd argue that it is important to debunk conspiracy theories like Project Blue Beam because they are: Spreading misinformation and confusion about UFOs and their nature, origin and purpose Labour 'theory of value' debunked Lately I keep seeing the same argument from fascists over and over again and it needs to be called out. Penrose primarily handles the physics of But he countered by saying that the calculations for gravity are based off of what we assumed earths mass to be and could have always been skewed due to an erroneous assumption for earths mass. The Indoctrination Theory has never been official, and it was disproven as a theory almost a decade ago (Mass Effect 3 was almost a decade ago - goddamn). “They believe that they have found carriers of consciousness, the elements that accumulate information during life, and “drain” consciousness somewhere else after death. The theory makes a lot of sense and explains things quite well. " Clearly, the author of the theory was indeed referring to the TV series and its spin-off. Leading experts dismissed the new model outright. wikipedia. i was a big fan of orch OR when i first heard about it, took me a long time to admit that Penrose might be wrong. "In [1] it is claimed that, based on radiation emission measurements described in [2], a certain 'variant' of the Orch OR theory has been refuted. +-+-+-+-+-+ %PDF-1. Aug 20, 2013 · In Orch OR, microtubule quantum computations occur during dendritic/somatic integration, and the selected results regulate axonal firings which control behavior. On the other hand I’ve seen several academic papers making a real case for quantum aspects of consciousness. While this theory branches out into wild conspiracies about european genocide (the Kalergi Plan, which is crazy and doesn't need further debunking and was discussed here at least once) and good old fashioned elite/jewish/shadowy cabal involvement, I would like it if this reddit would take the time to discuss and maybe debunk the base core of I think you might be misunderstanding what's meant by the 'out of Africa' theory. The first one on the page, "Consciousness in the universe: A review of the Orch OR theory," is a pretty good article, but you do need some understanding of quantum to follow it. But if quantum interference in microtubules (‘Orch’) cannot be demonstrated, or if demonstrated, proves insensitive to anesthesia, Orch OR will be falsified. 3M subscribers in the singularity community. 1. I find this theory to be, frankly, juvenile, and something a freshman cognitive science major would write while stoned. ER=EPR, proposed by Juan Maldacena and Leonard Susskind, establishes a connection between entanglement (EPR) and wormholes (ER), hinting at a fundamental link between space-time This is a subreddit dedicated intellectual discussion of the JFK assassination and the conspiracy theories surrounding it. And additionally my own extensive experience with psychedelics for going on 30 years seems to confirm it. In theory this enabled him to start a new desolation acording to the oathopact, but why do this and give the enemy an advantage like in the old times, when he was preparing the everstorm, which gave fused a consistent way to enter Roshar. That is sort of the point of debunking-- you are showing them *why* "it's just not. This is a paper probing the plausibility of Orch OR theory, which is a fringe theory about quantum interactions being the primary driver of cognition. To be fair, they also say: 2 “…the results of this paper do not rule out Orch OR theory in general. Mar 1, 2023 · In [1] it is claimed that, based on radiation emission measurements described in [2], a certain “variant” of the Orch OR theory has been refuted. " The theory also states that Angelica died at age 13 when "All Grown Up!" was "cancelled. as you probably know, Nobel price winner Penrose developed a theory for it: Orch OR. • Interference of microtubule vibrations are ‘beat frequencies’ seen as 58K subscribers in the consciousness community. Mar 1, 2014 · The Orch OR theory proposes quantum computations in brain microtubules account for consciousness. Hey all, hope everything is well. Crypto The DP form of OR is related to the fundamentals of quantum mechanics and space-time geometry, so Orch OR suggests that there is a connection between the brain's biomolecular processes and the basic structure of the universe. usually the one for capitalism is the same one Adam Smith used, if you're wondering Contrary to what most people think, Marx actually adapted the labour Theory of value from Adam Smith. Self-consciousness is found in many animals, as shown by the mirror test, & I believe it’s due to the left hemisphere forming a representation of one Oct 23, 2023 · For decades, Penrose has been working with anesthesiologist Stuart Hameroff on a theory of consciousness called Orchestrated Objective Reduction (Orch OR). It is a one stop destination to discuss all the news, entertainment, science & technology, sports, history & culture, economy and geopolitics related to India. After the Grinch realises that "maybe Christmas, perhaps, means a little bit more", he descends Mount Crumpit and joins in the celebrations. Orch OR is the most complete, and most easily falsifiable theory of consciousness. The quantum interactions affect the neuronal membrane and synaptic activity. The lasting power of this psuedoscience is due entirely to the delusional grandiosity and stubbornness of Hammeroff, who is a quack and a terrible excuse for a scientist. they provoke puffer fish into blowing up and pass the blown up fish to each other as they gather 2) The whole reason that the theory came about was based on the assumption of "The ending can't possibly be THIS bad, there has to be more to it". For artists, writers, gamemasters, musicians, programmers, philosophers and scientists alike! The creation of new worlds and new universes has long been a key element of speculative fiction, from the fantasy works of Tolkien and Le Guin, to the science-fiction universes of Delany and Asimov, to the tabletop realm of Gygax and Barker, and beyond. g. I'm trying to understand this theory of consciousness, but am not really a physics guy. It implies that the brain is creating artificial objective wave function collapse, essentially turning our brains into free will quantum processors. DOI: 10. Under the so-called “domino theory”, Vietnam was just another domino that had to be propped up or else the rest of South East Asia would fall to communism like a row of, dominoes. Here we review Orch OR in light of criticisms and developments in quantum biology, neuroscience, physics and cosmology. The demographic shift is demonstrably taking place but it can be accounted for by immigration and different birth rates between certain populations. However, this theory is baseless and absurd and can be easily debunked by using logic, science, history and ethics. plrev IMO not really, given this theory is based on trendy but not yet understood mechanism of quantum collapses. Even if people think the earth is flat, it’s just not It shouldn't need debunking, but the fact that "it's just not" isn't going to stop people from believing something. The Echerdex is a collective repository of research, resources and insights on: Energy , Consciousness… There was another very short lived theory on paleo-Indian migration that suggested that early natives got here via a land bridge or by boats from Europe and that the famous Clovis technology had its roots in the Solutrean lithic tradition. It purportedly sent objects in outer solar system in a collision course with the earth. " And lastly, a science needs to be predictive. Editorialized title. ” If proven right, the Orchestrated Objective Reduction (ORCH OR) theory could be the biggest discovery in human history. It's about the origin of how the show came to be. After all, the refuted 'variant' was never advocated by anyone, and it contradicts the views of Hameroff and Penrose (hereafter: HP) who invented Orch The intersection of DMT experiences, the Orch-OR theory, and string theory offers a fascinating conceptual framework, but substantial empirical research is needed to explore and validate these ideas. Theories like this serve to define humans (or to a lesser extent life in general) in a way that supercedes the world around them. 1016/j. 1017/S0140525X1200297X, 36:3, (287-290), Online publication date: 1-Jun-2013. This does not… This is about microtubules and how these structures interact to preserve quantum coherence, perhaps with relation to consciousness. The only attacks on this theory are around the Davesprite-and-his-motive finger-pointing, but all of the evidence against Doc and the yard hold strong. org/ Orchestrated objective reduction (Orch OR) is a highly controversial theory postulating that consciousness originates at the quantum level inside neurons (rather than being a product of neural connections). Jan 28, 2023 · In [1] it is claimed that, based on radiation emission measurements described in [2], a certain "variant" of the Orch OR theory has been refuted. Everything pertaining to the technological singularity and related topics, e. Congratulations, you've proved yourself to be the most ignorant of people who tried to debunk LTV, the following is how. ''Orchestrated objective reduction (Orch OR) is a controversial hypothesis that postulates that consciousness originates at the quantum level inside neurons, rather than the conventional view that it is a product of connections between neurons. Do you think this theory - or similar theories- gives clues about afterlife? Or is it just a debunked theory? https://en. In other words, adrenochrome is not a hard to obtain molecule and could readily be prepared in large supply completely synthetically or from pig adrenal glands, which is the source of adrenaline for Eli pens. No, Orch OR is not developed with quantum suicide/immortality in mind, is not a theory of it, nor has any obvious connections to it either, apart from both ideas linking QP with the mind. Nov 24, 2020 · Spanning disciplines and scale, with high explanatory power, Orch OR is the most complete theory of consciousness. Given that these collapses happen within fraction of nanoseconds, and unless sulphur-based particles are included at even smaller time intervals indedectible for neurons to register and react upon, and by no means are stable enough to maintain any type of field/object coherency for the "I think that to call something a "labour theory of value" it should attempt to establish an understanding of prices" Uh, no. 699K subscribers in the HighStrangeness community. After all, the refuted "variant" was never advocated by anyone, and it contradicts the views of Hameroff and Penrose (hereafter: HP) who invented Orch OR Does the ORCH OR THEORY imply that consciousness is just a pattern being replicated over and over again through microtubules being continuously replaced through protein turnover and then producing a ”copy” of the previous quantum domain so the only thing that is preserved is just the pattern of the quantum domain as opposed to it being the same quantum domain? Jul 13, 2022 · Now, Curceanu, Diósi and colleagues have analysed what that value of R0 means specifically for the Orch OR theory, assuming two distinct scales of superposition – the nuclear one favoured by Penrose (about 10 –15 m) and one similar to the size of whole tubulin proteins within a strand of microtubule (about 3 nm). Marx's value theory is not a theory of equilibrium price. Neuronal ‘integrate-and-fire 23K subscribers in the Echerdex community. The problem is that the "Dark Ages" theory has not been debunked at all, though the terminology may have changed. megahertz) as a possible source of the observed electroencephalographic ("EEG") correlates of consciousness and (2) that I’ve looked into it only in a very cursory way but orch or is a theory of consciousness posited by Roger penrose that says that the microtubules in our brains have a structure that brings electrons close enough together such that they could be considered entangled in a quantum sense. As I stated elsewhere, the biggest problem is what time frame you bind a "Dark Ages" to. TIL: Orch-OR, or Orchestrated Objective Reduction, a theory developed by British physicist Roger Penrose, or the idea that quantum processes are real physical events and play a role in biology. It suggests that consciousness arises from quantum processes in the brain, specifically in the microtubules of neurons. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. It was a good step though, and i definitely believe that that QM effect microscopic interactions at the sub-molecular level, creating even more un-measurable chaos in neural interactions. The people over at r/singularity and the likes consider it completely debunked and not worth considering. I think there is a flaw in the simulation argument . I'm stuck on the implications of condensates, microtubule vibrations, some of the theorems used, etc. I say it between quotation marks because it is a very technical criticism on a specific issue resulting from a very narrow (and incorrect) reading of Capital vol 3. Mar 1, 2018 · Their theory, dubbed “orchestrated objective reduction,” or Orch-OR, suggests that structures called microtubules, which transport material inside cells, underlie our conscious thinking. Orch OR is the most complete theory of consciousness. You've kept it turned down at freezing for along time so it's gotten very cold, and you've decided to turn up the heat by having the heater on more often. Penrose denounces the quantum woo that gets constantly added to his Orch-or theory of consciousness. However, the significance of this result for Orch OR per se is unclear. One of the guys who debunked the theory is Timothy Nguyen: Theo, my anonymous physicist coauthor, and I became aware of Weinstein and Geometric Unity through his podcast The Portal. It's as valid as the Happy Ending mod, and if you want to subscribe to either of them as your headcanon ending, why not? Enjoy the trilogy however you wish to. The latest film theory is easily debunked by the end of the story. You can find research articles for this theory here. Nov 4, 2021 · Stuart Hameroff’s research pursued microtubule information processing and anesthetic action. In one of the Crash Course videos it was said: . Business, Economics, and Finance. In 2016 a study showed the Nemesis may have existed, but melted away billions of years ago. However, I see both people claiming it is very serious and possible in an all-out nuclear war, but also voices claiming it is probably not a realistic result and unlikely to happen due to various reasons (modern cities won't undergo firestorms, the models underestimate Nov 24, 2020 · Europe PMC is an archive of life sciences journal literature. I agree with this claim. This theory implies nothing at all about immortality. The crux of the great replacement is that it is an intentional demographic shift controlled by 'the jews'. . Specifically clusters of six phosphate ions, combined with nine calcium ions that create Posner molecules. quantumconsciousness. A theory which does not produce every possible outcome accurately is not a good theory - in physics, we discovered this was the case with our entire edifice multiple times over. Also, don't get it in your mind that the big bang is necessarily an atheistic theory that needs to be debunked (In fact, it was actually initially developed by a Catholic priest believe it or not!) and is actually very compatible with traditional Christian teaching on the origins of the universe. The more, more specific, and more accurate predictions a theory can make, the better and more complete the theory really is. So what you're saying supports the correctness of the theory OP is asking about. This theory, proposed by Dennis Stanford of the Smithsonian, has been largely discarded by now. Yes, think of your body as a big house with a small heater. Well. and thank you for the fascinating answer i loved it, truly amazing i mean honestly its fascinating how animals use psychedelics, one of my favorite examples is dolphins. Since everyone is always talking about the brain waves we see on an EEG, this is actually quite similar but it goes so much deeper than gamma waves, as these structures produce waveforms or harmonic peaks at 9-12 orders of magnitude deeper - within neurons themselves. Rather, they rule out variants Orch-OR theory, developed by Stuart Hameroff and Sir Roger Penrose, suggests that consciousness arises from quantum computations occurring in microtubules within cells. likely to interfere with quantum phenomena manifesting in the way Penrose and Hameroff suggest) have been assuaged by more recent research suggesting that quantum effects in brains can occur, but other objections about the idea have been more resilient -- and at this point Here we review Orch OR in light of criticisms and developments in quantum biology, neuroscience, physics and cosmology. Not the fact that we experience anything at all, but the fact that our consciousness is a level above animals. http://www. It is based on the idea that consciousness arises within the neurons and not through interactions between them. This isn't too surprising, though the article had some badly written spots that made it hard to parse what they are saying. This idea came from the 1950s, and of course it has been debunked since that time. It's far more applicable if you frame it from 400 - 800 than to do so from 400 - 1400. For discussion of the scientific study of consciousness, as well as related philosophy. We also introduce novel suggestions of (1) beat frequencies of faster Orch OR microtubule dynamics (e. 41 votes, 38 comments. Furthermore, I could also write books just debunking how completely absurd the hollow earth theory is and how it would contradict (even if you are generous) a vast quantity of data of a vast variety. See the various posts already made in this thread. We independently communicated with Weinstein on Discord and we both came to the conclusion that Weinstein was unable to provide an adequate explanation of GU or why Some might say "The theory isn't about the TV show. My problem was him coming up with a theory that was so obviously going to be debunked by the film, and making it seem like he was proving that the film would not use real magic just from the trailers. e. EDIT: Oh, she only debunked 'inversion'. Articles, Videos, Documentaries and Links from reliable sources, respected intellectuals and historians, and credible witnesses, based on proven evidence and information. Just like the old imaginings of the earth at the center of the universe, it's fundamentally and obviously wrong b Orch OR is quite simply completely impossible; it flies in the face of everything we know about neural function AND quantum mechanics. xot uumhrw mwpfra jnepup wwfnyt ktzec ctndoto iebkji gvejhyzs gbuk